Lost in the Desert

Faith Blog

Our Latest Blog Articles

alcheltron
  1. Flirting with Fideism

    "Each Chrisitan generation must undertake" “the synthetic passage through both Athens and Jerusalem."

    Read More
  2. The Trump Election and Freedom of Thought

    The Trump Election and Freedom of Thought
    In a recent “Points of View” episode on BBC Radio 4[1], the well-known philosopher, Professor Roger Scruton, gave a reasoned analysis of something that may explain the surprise election of Donald Trump in America and of the Brexit vote here in the UK. Although clearly not a supporter ...
    Read More
  3. Bishop Barron Misses the Impact of Modern Science

    Bishop Barron Misses the Impact of Modern Science
    On his blog and in a recent Catholic Herald piece (9.9.16) Bishop Robert Barron offers some excellent reflections upon a recent Pew survey looking at reasons why young people are leaving Christianity in droves. He well shows how Roman Catholic leaders and teachers are dangerously underestimating ...
    Read More
  4. Jeff Mirus illustrates the fulfillment of Holloway's 1950 prediction.

    Jeff Mirus illustrates the fulfillment of Holloway's 1950 prediction.
    Jeff Mirus writes here on modern murder mystery novels. He says “Unfortunately, I’ve run into a number of telling cultural trends in these stories which make it more difficult to relax and enjoy the solution to 'a good clean murder'". He well articulates the over represen...
    Read More
  5. Contextualising Brexit

    Contextualising Brexit
    On 23 June 2016 a referendum was held in which a narrow majority of voters in the United Kingdom (nearly 52%) voted in favour of leaving the European Union, the so-called “Brexit”. This contrasts with the large majority (67%) who had voted to join the then European Community in 1975. ...
    Read More
  6. A 1980 Post-mortem of a Rebirth

    A 1980 Post-mortem of a Rebirth
    Thirty odd years after this overview of twentieth century Catholic intellectual culture, the points of James Hitchcock seem even more relevant. Below are some extracts but the, significantly longer, full article repays study. [Post-mortem on a rebirth. The Catholic Intellectual Renaissance, from ...
    Read More
  7. 'Desire Trumping Ideas': A Too Simple Diagnosis

    'Desire Trumping Ideas': A Too Simple Diagnosis
    The great analyser of relativist culture, Jeff Mirus, seems to have downplayed a bit too much the role of the intellectual. In part of his insightful series on “gender” ideology he argues: (our comments in blue).Modern Western culture is weakened by a great vacuum of systematic though...
    Read More
  8. Refounding Human Dignity

    Refounding Human Dignity
    A Guardian editorial in May described the decline in numbers and influence of Christianity and affirms that Christianity gave us “the idea that people have some rights just because they are human, and entirely irrespective of merit, [it] certainly isn’t derived from observat...
    Read More
  9. Experimental Success contra Aristotelean Natures

    Experimental Success contra Aristotelean Natures
    Mgr Charles Pope recently turned his deft blogging hand to a subject close to our heart. Pulling up Roots from Reality – A Review of a Cogent Analysis of the Post-Cartesian West.Like Fr Edward Holloway and others he acknowledges that a key moment in the rise of relativism was René De...
    Read More
  10. The Benedict Centre and Public Life

    The Benedict Centre and Public Life
    On 6th May, the Catholic Herald published a news article by Dan Hitchens entitled:“St Mary’s University launches Benedict XVI Centre to ‘play a key role in public life’”The centre is a good fruit of Pope Benedict’s visit to Britain in 2010, when he ca...
    Read More
  11. The Rights Juggernaut and the Weakest of the Weak.

    The Rights Juggernaut and the Weakest of the Weak.
    Comments to blog@faith.org.uk (which will be moderated) or twitter to @faithmovukIt is always worth keeping in mind that it is the little ones who must first pay the price of the cultural rejection of ‘human nature’. An item in last Sunday’s “Sunday programme” illust...
    Read More
  12. Meeting the Modern Mindset.

    Meeting the Modern Mindset.
    Here’s a powerful three minutes showing where the denial of “the nature of things” has got us.This further illustrates the deep infiltration of the philosophical position of ‘swing vote’ Justice Kennedy, which we recently blogged about: "the constitution &hellip...
    Read More
  13. BBC allows Lemaitre to witness to harmony of Faith and Reason

    BBC allows Lemaitre to witness to harmony of Faith and Reason
    The BBC recently produced an excellent two-part programme concerning the beginning and end of the universe (available until 28th April). The presenter, Prof. Jim Al-Khalili, is a regular presenter of “The Life Scientific” on Radio 4 and has presented several television series on scien...
    Read More
  14. Tony Blair Moves Towards Pope Benedict

    Tony Blair Moves Towards Pope Benedict
    Comments to blog@faith.org.uk (which will be moderated) or twitter to @faithmovuk1. “Theology must become part of the solution if it is not to remain at the heart of the problem”. This is a key theme of Rabbi Sacks’ recent book “Not in God’s Name”  concern...
    Read More
  15. Which comes first in Kerygmatic Catechesis: Sin or Christ?

    Which comes first in Kerygmatic Catechesis: Sin or Christ?
    The indefatigably insightful Msgr Charles Pope has recently plotted a helpful way forward for kerygmatic catechesis. Yet his content starts with, “Part 1 (Sept. to Jan.) – Sin – ‘I once was lost in sin’”A Mr Miller puts an attractive alternative ...
    Read More
  16. 5 Similar Diagnoses of Marriage Redefinition

    5 Similar Diagnoses of Marriage Redefinition
    1. The US Supreme Court’s “swing vote” Justice Kennedy gives a clue to the philosophy sweeping through our culture (not least through his actual votes). He builds his moral judgments upon the absence of a concept of human nature.In a March 4th Catholic Herald article, “The...
    Read More
  17. Priestly loving: The BBC versus St John Paul II

    Priestly loving: The BBC versus St John Paul II
    In the November 2008 FAITH magazine Fr William Massie, reflects upon Edward Holloway’s pamphlet, “The Priest and His Loving”. A prophetic 1974 foundation of this pamphlet is in the current magazine. Fr Massie quoted this St John Paul II imperative to priests:be a witness to Chri...
    Read More
  18. Towards Diagnosis: Two more pieces on the pre-Vatican II era.

    Towards Diagnosis: Two more pieces on the pre-Vatican II era.
    In support of seeing a lack of appropriate theological development before the 1960s (see previous post) is a piece by Jeff Mirus. He concludes:“Too often Catholics prefer[ed] to condemn rather than to engage the rapidly secularizing society … When the culture shifted, their...
    Read More
  19. To What Degree Did The Pre-Vatican II Church ‘Cause’ The Decline Of It's Influence?

    To What Degree Did The Pre-Vatican II Church ‘Cause’ The Decline Of It's Influence?
    In an earlier blog post we flagged up a recent Catholic Herald piece showing the need for a diagnosis of how classical Christianity came to drop the reins of cultural influence. http://tinyurl.com/nrk454mThe Winter 2013 “Mass of Ages” provides another piece of evidence. The Latin Mass...
    Read More
  20. Mediating between the New Atheists and the new apologists

    Mediating between the New Atheists and the new apologists
    Comments to blog@faith.org.uk (which will be moderated) or twitter to @faithmovukProfessor Tom McLeish of Durham University recently made a common Christian reply to the New Atheist claim that science and faith are opposed. On Radio Ulster he affirmed that science “uses our capacity for fai...
    Read More
  21. The Magi: not just a story.

    The Magi: not just a story.
    Available for the next few weeks, BBC iPlayer has an interesting exploration of astronomical possibilities for the Star of Bethlehem (though beware a juvenile short section from The Life of Brian, and a lazy equivalence of pre-modern science astrology and “devout Christianity&rdqu...
    Read More
  22. Civil Law and the Homosexual Person

    Civil Law and the Homosexual Person
    Mark Lowery FAITH Magazine July-August 2002“You Can’t Legislate Morality?”Why can’t you just let us do what we want to do?” “How does this harm you?” “Don’t impose your morality on us!” “If you don’t like this,...
    Read More
  23. FAQ: Why is the Church so homophobic? If two people love each other, shouldn't they be allowed to get married, regardless of their sex?

    FAQ: Why is the Church so homophobic? If two people love each other, shouldn't they be allowed to get married, regardless of their sex?
    The Catholic Church promotes the dignity and welfare of every human individual regardless of whom they are sexually attracted to. The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that those with homosexual tendencies must “be accepted with respect, compassion and sensitivity” (2358) and &...
    Read More
  24. Hard Questions - a new series of talks in London

    Hard Questions - a new series of talks in London
    "Hard Questions" is a new series of talks that will take place in Central London and is run by Faith Movement to which all are welcome. The talks will take place on selected Tuesdays at 7:30pm.God and Our Environment29 September 2015 Is man an ape or an angel? Fr Roger Nesbitt...
    Read More
  25. In Defence of Frequent Communion

    In Defence of Frequent Communion
    Check out the this Editorial addressing the issue of the reception of Holy Communion and the value of regularly receiving the body and blood of the Lord for the sanctification of the faithful. ...
    Read More
  26. Three excellent resources & two caveats

    Three excellent resources & two caveats
    Fr Barron’s “Catholicism”:  catholicism.wordonfire.org/Portsmouth Diocese's new Confirmation programme:  www.transformedinchrist.com/session1/Westminster Diocese’s brand new singing and dancing youth page, where the CTS has provided the “Catholicism&rdq...
    Read More
  27. The Need for Diagnosis

    The Need for Diagnosis
    Stephen Bullivant says in this recently published piece:“Just think at your next Easter Vigil, for every new person coming through the RCIA – over whom we are right to rejoice – 10 people have drifted so far away that they no longer tick the “Catholic” box on surveys...
    Read More
  28. ARCHIVE: Saint Philip Neri - A Guide to Chastity

    ARCHIVE: Saint Philip Neri - A Guide to Chastity
    Richard Whinder FAITH Magazine July-Aug 2007St Philip Neri, (1515-1595) founder of the Congregation of the Oratory, and often called the ‘Second Apostle of Rome’, has many titles attributed to him. Two of these – ‘Flower of Purity’ and ‘Gentle Guide of You...
    Read More
  29. In a hurry? More than you realise!

    In a hurry? More than you realise!
    It’s tempting to think the universe is rather static. So thanks to Msgr Charles Pope http://tiny.cc/8deiux for the following information:At the latitude of Washington D.C., the Earth is rotating at about 750 miles an hour. [401c.html">1]The rotating Earth is also revolving around the Sun at ...
    Read More
  30. Our Lady In The Teaching of Pope Benedict XVI

    Our Lady In The Teaching of Pope Benedict XVI
    Check out one of the new articles in the January - February edition of FAITH Magazine on Our Lady In The Teaching of Pope Benedict XVI. You can subscribe to FAITH Magazine here. ...
    Read More
  31. New Series Of Talks In Glasgow!

    New Series Of Talks In Glasgow!
    The Glasgow Faith Forum has just announced a new series of talks which will take place on Thursday evenings over the next few months. All talks are followed by questions, refreshments and Night Prayer and aimed at young people aged between 16 and 25. Get more information at the Glasgow Faith Foru...
    Read More
  32. New Year Series of London talks!

    New Year Series of London talks!
    The London Faith Forum is back with another series of talks which take place on alternate Tuesday evenings in January, February and March. The series, entitled The Church and Other Beliefs, features a host of good speakers addressing important questions concerning the nature of the Church and its...
    Read More
  33. Great Start to Faith Winter Session 2014!

    Great Start to Faith Winter Session 2014!
    Faith Winter Session 2014 began yesterday at Stonyhurst College, Lancashire with around 200 young Catholics from across the UK in attendance. Bishop Mark Davies of Shrewsbury preached at Mass yesterday evening about St Thomas of Canterbury and how his yes to God should inspire young people to hav...
    Read More
  34. FAQ: Why did God wait for so long to come and help us?

    FAQ: Why did God wait for so long to come and help us?
    The time before God becoming man is the period in which He gradually comes closer to mankind, fostering the fullness of life, as well as healing from sin and its effects. The help of God has never been absent from human history, even from the time of humanity’s Fall. But it is true tha...
    Read More
  35. The Primacy of Christ in the Vision of Edward Holloway

    The Primacy of Christ in the Vision of Edward Holloway
    Fr. Michael John Galbraith. FAITH Magazine January-February 2006 The Unity of Truth In his Encyclical Fides et Ratio, Pope John Paul II reminded us that, “the unity of truth is a fundamental premise of human reasoning... Revelation renders this unity certain, showing tha...
    Read More
  36. FAQ: Why do Catholics have to go to Mass on Sunday? Why not Monday?

    FAQ: Why do Catholics have to go to Mass on Sunday? Why not Monday?
    In the Old Testament God commanded his people to keep holy the Sabbath. The Church, which is the new People of God, observes Sunday as the Sabbath in commemoration of the Resurrection of Christ which happened on a Sunday. We keep holy our Sabbath by attending Mass and in this way obeying Christ&r...
    Read More
  37. ARCHIVE: The Cardinal, the Pope & the Scientists

    ARCHIVE: The Cardinal, the Pope & the Scientists
    Editorial FAITH Magazine November-December 2005If they had the power to know so much that they could investigate the world, how did they fail to find sooner the Lord of these things? (Wisdom 13,9).Science And The Magisterium, A New ControversyHis Eminence Cardinal Schonborn managed to spark ...
    Read More
  38. ARCHIVE: Holiness is Fitting for your House, O Lord

    ARCHIVE: Holiness is Fitting for your House, O Lord
    Editorial FAITH Magazine September-October 2003“If anything constant remains in our days of recurring crisis, it is that the certainties have gone out of life, out of the life of the individual and out of the life of society.It is a heartbreaking realisation.The feeling of insecurity i...
    Read More
  39. FAQ: If disease & death are a result of Original Sin, then how come they affect organisms that cannot sin & predate the Fall?

    FAQ: If disease & death are a result of Original Sin, then how come they affect organisms that cannot sin & predate the Fall?
    Properly speaking, it is human suffering and death which are a result of the Fall, not disease and death in the purely material creation. Clearly, if God gave humans and animals the plants for food (Gen 1:29-30), then He envisaged that plants would die before the Fall. And presuming that we are n...
    Read More
  40. ARCHIVE: The Crusades - Seeking the Truth

    ARCHIVE: The Crusades - Seeking the Truth
    Nicholas Schofield FAITH Magazine May-June 2006The crusades capture the imagination – but over the years they have done so in many different ways. Here are three modern examples:When I was a boy, I spent many a happy hour with my toy soldiers. I was particularly keen on playing ‘...
    Read More
  41. FAQ: How can God be loving when Abraham is tricked into thinking God wants him to kill his only child?

    FAQ: How can God be loving when Abraham is tricked into thinking God wants him to kill his only child?
    We must understand that what we read in the book of Genesis comes from a religion and culture which is at its early stages of growing into a relationship with God. What Genesis recounts can be difficult and confusing for us who have the benefit of having heard the message of Christ communicated t...
    Read More
  42. ARCHIVE: How are we to assess Islam?

    ARCHIVE: How are we to assess Islam?
    Edouard Harmouche FAITH Magazine September-October 2003Catholicism is still the largest religious group in the world with over a billion adherents. After that come somewhere in the region of 900 million Muslims, who currently form the fastest growing religious group on the planet. This is re...
    Read More
  43. CURRENT MAGAZINE: The Gospel & Cultures

    CURRENT MAGAZINE: The Gospel & Cultures
    Michael Nazir Ali FAITH MAGAZINE September-October 2014The last few weeks I have been closely engaged with the people and scholars of two ancient cultures – that of Egypt and of Mughal India. This has raised afresh for me the question about the relationship of the Gospel to culture.In ...
    Read More
  44. FAQ: What does the Pope do?

    FAQ: What does the Pope do?
    The Pope maintains the public unity of the Church. This unity in belief and witness is essential if Jesus’ role of humanly forming and feeding us with Himself is to be continued.The Apostle Peter was the first to be given this role, as is shown in Holy Scripture. The Pope is his “Succ...
    Read More
  45. ARCHIVE: The Spirit moves over the waters: renewing our vision of the Sacraments

    ARCHIVE: The Spirit moves over the waters: renewing our vision of the Sacraments
    Editorial FAITH Magazine September-October 2007 Why Sacraments?  This editorial article takes more the character of a sustained theological meditation than a topical or controversial ‘op-ed’ piece. There is good precedent for this approach in the magnificent editorials ...
    Read More
  46. London Evening of Faith Success!

    London Evening of Faith Success!
    The first of our Evenings of Faith kicked off this week on Tuesday evening with a talk on Original Sin by Mary Gray. The event was well attended by University students and workers in the city of London gathering to listen, ask questions and interact with one another over a glass of wine and pizza...
    Read More
  47. FAQ: If something good happens after someone prays, and the same thing happens to one who doesn't pray for it - how can you prove that the prayer was answered?

    FAQ: If something good happens after someone prays, and the same thing happens to one who doesn't pray for it - how can you prove that the prayer was answered?
    God is free to bestow gifts on people even if they don’t ask for them! Does a parent only provide good things for their children if they specifically ask? Moreover, God, who alone sees all things and what is necessary, treats us as the unique individuals He created us to be; not a ‘on...
    Read More
  48. ARCHIVE: A Time for Listening to the Ordinary Magisterium

    ARCHIVE: A Time for Listening to the Ordinary Magisterium
    Editorial FAITH Magazine July-August 2003The Swiss priest Hans Kung ranks among the most famous theologians of our times, and it is interesting to note that Prime Minister Tony Blair has met with him on a number of occasions and says he has been influenced by his thought. However it should b...
    Read More
  49. Glasgow Faith Forum gears up for Spring Session

    Glasgow Faith Forum gears up for Spring Session
      GLASGOW FAITH FORUM 2016a series of talks for young people aged 16–25 HERALDS OF THE NEW EVANGELISATION    THE BAPTISMAL CALL TO EVANGELISE 21 JanuaryPriest, prophet and king Father Peter Damian Grint   EVANGELISATION THEN 4 February Procl...
    Read More
  50. Why was the Crucifixion necessary? Could not God have saved us in a way less cruel?

    Why was the Crucifixion necessary? Could not God have saved us in a way less cruel?
    God is not responsible for the brutality of the crucifixion. On the contrary, the crucifixion is the result of human sinfulness. This is because human wickedness has real consequences, and therefore our redemption (i.e. how God saves us from our sins) is not just about God “turning a blind ...
    Read More
  51. ARCHIVE: A Short History of Science & Christianity

    ARCHIVE: A Short History of Science & Christianity
    Peter E Hodgson FAITH Magazine November-December 2008It is becoming increasingly recognised, at least within the Church, that science has developed only in the context of a Christian civilisation, and has deep Christian roots.If we consider the great civilisations of the past such as those o...
    Read More
  52. FAQ: If God is All-Good, why do bad things happen?

    FAQ: If God is All-Good, why do bad things happen?
    God has created different sorts of things. In particular He has created matter, which is simply controlled by His laws of nature (the laws we attempt to discover in the natural sciences). He has also created spiritual beings, angels and human souls, which have free will; they are also govern...
    Read More
  53. What has Ethiopia to Teach us?

    What has Ethiopia to Teach us?
    Bishop Michael Nazir-Ali FAITH MAGAZINE July-August 2014The introduction of Christianity to Ethiopia is charted in the Acts of the Apostles. The contemporary story of this ancient Christian church, though, has much to teach us, says Bishop Michael Nazir-Ali.The St Frumentius Lectures in Addi...
    Read More
  54. FAQ: What does being Confirmed mean?

    FAQ: What does being Confirmed mean?
    We are made members of the Body of Christ through receiving three sacraments - Baptism, Confirmation,  which we receive only once, and the Holy Eucharist which is Christ Himself. Confirmation completes and strengthens ('confirms') the spiritual “character” and belonging t...
    Read More
  55. New edition of Faith Magazine online!

    New edition of Faith Magazine online!
    The New July-August edition of Faith Magazine is now online. ...
    Read More
  56. New series of talks in London!

    New series of talks in London!
    All are welcome to our Autumn series of talks Jesus Christ and Human Love.The talks are a great opportunity to deepen your faith and to connect with other Catholics.Talks will take place on alternate Tuesday evenings at 19:30 from 23rd September in the Crypt of Our Lady of Assumption Catholi...
    Read More
  57. Summer Session Roundup Video!

    Summer Session Roundup Video!
    The Faith Summer Session 2014 was as good as any in recent memory, set in the beautiful grounds of Woldingham School in Surrey. The theme was especially relevent given contemporary challenges to family life and the upcoming Synod on that subject.Here our very own David Edwards provides a quick su...
    Read More
  58. ARCHIVE: Confusion over the Meanings of Marriage

    ARCHIVE: Confusion over the Meanings of Marriage
    Editorial FAITH Magazine March-April 2006The "Ends" of Marriage: An Unresolved TeachingThe old Code of Canon Law (1917) stated that “the primary end of marriage is the procreation and education of offspring; the secondary end is mutual love and support, and the remedying of c...
    Read More
  59. New photos from Faith Summer Session!

    New photos from Faith Summer Session!
    See more photos in the new album on our Facebook page and please like us too!   ...
    Read More
  60. Summer Session Success!

    Summer Session Success!
    The Faith Summer Session 2014 has just come to a close. Young people from across the UK and beyond gathered to hear talks on the topic of The Family In God's Plan and the Modern World. The Summer Session combines time for presentations on the faith, daily Mass, prayer and the opportunity for ...
    Read More
  61. Summer Session 2014 Update

    Summer Session 2014 Update
    See our new video update from the Faith Summer Session 2014. Sr Andrea Frailie describes what has been going on at the conference so far which is addressing the theme of The Family in God's Plan and The Modern World. She speaks about the presentation she gave to the conference on th...
    Read More
  62. Summer Session 2014 begins!

    Summer Session 2014 begins!
    Faith Summer Session 2014 has begun at Woldingham School, Surrey. The Conference is for those aged 16-35 and is addressing the theme "The Family in God's Plan and in the Modern World". The first speaker of the conference was Dr Stephen Dingley, tutor of Theology at St John's Sem...
    Read More
  63. FAQ: What is Papal Infallibility?

    FAQ: What is Papal Infallibility?
    Papal Infallibility refers to the fact that the Pope is divinely preserved from teaching error in his formal teaching on faith and morals. It flows from the divinity of Christ in the Church. God is infallible, and He has irrevocably entered the human realm by becoming man. The Church is the conti...
    Read More
  64. Why Do We Sin?

    Why Do We Sin?
    Having spiritual souls means that we have free will. We are not bound to do what is good for us by instinct. This also means that we can refuse to do what is good. God did not make us this way as some sort of test, but because he wanted us to be in his own image and likeness. God is Love and love...
    Read More
  65. FAQ: Why does matter need a cause?

    FAQ: Why does matter need a cause?
    It is part of our everyday experience that material things need causes. If you discovered an elephant in your sitting room, you would immediately ask yourself how it got to be there. You would not think, “Oh well, maybe it’s just here for no reason: elephants often just turn up like t...
    Read More
  66. Why The Church?

    Why The Church?
    Why The Church? Come and see our video....
    Read More
  67. FAQ: What about the Crusades?

    FAQ: What about the Crusades?
    Jesus is ‘the Prince of Peace’ (Is. 9:6). As St John Paul II said, war always represents a defeat for humanity. Yet the Church is realistic about the presence of sin in the world, including amongst her own members, which produces conflict. Thus, while individual Catholics may adopt a ...
    Read More
  68. FAQ: What Scientific Evidence is there of God's Existence?

    FAQ: What Scientific Evidence is there of God's Existence?
    Science is concerned with the material universe and its ‘law-like’ behaviour. Catholic Christians believe that God created the universe and continues to hold it in being, i.e. without God's existence the universe cannot exist, so we should expect an interweaving harmony between sc...
    Read More
  69. ARCHIVE: The Truth About Same-Sex Marriage

    ARCHIVE: The Truth About Same-Sex Marriage
    William E May FAITH Magazine September-October 2004The Gay Case: Need For An Intelligent AnswerAdvocates of same-sex marriage commonly assert that its opponents are intolerant bigots unjustly denying a fundamental human right to individuals attracted to persons of the same sex. They maintain...
    Read More
  70. YES!!!

    YES!!!
    It's been a long overdue face-lift and lots of people have worked very hard with patience and caffeine so thanks to all you guys who have contributed to this project. Thanks to all the volunteers who've lent a hand in the run-up to going live. To all of you reading for the first time, giv...
    Read More
  71. Come and See!

    Come and See!
    Have you heard of us but don't know what we do? Maybe this is the first time you've encountered us. Take a look at our new promotional video and come and see us. Consider booking on one of our youth conferences or attending one of our forums. Connect with us on Facebook or Googl...
    Read More
  72. FAQ: What do nuns do?

    FAQ: What do nuns do?
    Before considering what nuns do, it’s more appropriate to reflect on what nuns are: regardless of the congregation or religious institute to which she belongs, making Christ present in the world is the nun’s primary mission. She does this by conforming herself entirely to the Person o...
    Read More
  • God and Evolution – the fundamental issue today

    The decline of Christian belief in the West is accelerating – last year a survey revealed that for the first time less than 50% of people in the U.K. now identify as Christians. And those brought up as Catholics are not exempt from this loss of faith. Why is this happening?

    The fundamental issue is that ‘scientific’ atheism, now popularised by writers such as Richard Dawkins, has gained intellectual ascendancy in our culture. Yet little official Church teaching has engaged with its arguments in a detailed and coherent way. The documents of Vatican II had many beautiful things to say, but they did not engage intellectually with atheism. The Church seemed to have accepted that the old arguments for the existence of God had been demolished by science, and it appeared that nobody had any new reasoned approaches to take. So in the decades following the Council, the old scholastic approach disappeared from seminaries; catechesis abandoned any element of reasoned apologetics and became experience-based. God was ‘given’; his existence could not be argued for, much less demonstrated.

    Liberalism vs. fundamentalism

    In this intellectual vacuum, a dichotomy has appeared. On the one hand, there is the liberal Christian who has abandoned traditional doctrine and barely seems to believe in God – certainly not in the divinity of Christ. The late Anglican Bishop of Durham, David Jenkins, became the best known of these. They have a following among a liberal elite, but their churches have emptied fastest of all. On the other hand, religious fundamentalism of the most bible-thumping, anti-intellectual kind has become identified in the public mind with mainstream Christian belief. If you’re religious, this is the sort of nutter you are, at least according to the media. This, of course, is greatly to atheists’ and secularists’ advantage.

    Evolution

    Evolution – the paradigm through which we understand all science – is the crunch issue. If Christians can apparently only maintain their full faith by rejecting evolution, then they have obviously lost the debate. A disturbing feature of recent decades is that whereas such anti-science fundamentalism was previously only to be found

    in simplistic ‘Bible belt’ churches, it can now be heard even from some Catholics. A package has emerged in some circles in which rejection of evolution is a badge of " traditionalism’. Our atheist opponents could not have wished for better confirmation of Catholicism’s decline into a weird, anti-intellectual sect. Such fundamentalism is an intellectual dead end.

    It is not, of course, the authentic Catholic tradition. From St Paul arguing that we can know God from ‘the things he has made’, to Aquinas’s monumental synthesising of theology with Aristotelian thought, through to Canon Nicholas Copernicus’s breakthrough about the shape of the cosmos, to Friar Gregor Mendel’s discovery of the laws of genetics, to Père George Lemaitre’s theory of the Big Bang – Catholic intellectuals have brought faith and science together. Pope St John Paul II’s encyclical Fides et Ratio (believed to be largely drafted by Joseph Ratzinger) made an appeal for this tradition to continue, but it has to be said that there has been little response.

    The need for intellectual argument

    The issue must be addressed. We cannot go on talking about God to an audience who think he has been disproved. It is no good our going on about Scripture if our audience thinks it has been shown to be no truer than the myths of other religions.

    We can’t escape the need for intellectual argument. Any RE teacher who tries to explain the Faith to teenagers knows this. You can be as ‘green’ and as enthusiastic about ‘justice and peace’ as you like – for an atheist teenager this is just icing on a non-existent cake. After all, you can be very committed to all these social issues without having to believe in God. In fact the Church can look as if it’s just jumping, belatedly, on a green or liberal political bandwagon. God is not reducible to social issues, no matter how worthy, and if we give the impression that these are all our faith is about, we are tacitly accepting that we’ve lost the intellectual argument about whether He exists at all.

    Of course, you can’t argue someone into belief if they don’t want to believe. But there are many youngsters who have been brought up in the Faith but who in adolescence are overwhelmed by the atheist intellectual atmosphere of our times and who begin to assume that you can’t have a modern scientific outlook and also be a Catholic - that God cannot be demonstrated to exist at all. It is to them that we can and must present the Faith in a way that is intellectually coherent – above all, not embarrassed or intimidated by the philosophy of science, but embracing it, using it to show the truth and beauty of our religion. Jesus is the One through whom and for whom the universe was made. He is not just another great soul in the history of world religions – he is the centre of all history, giving meaning to it all and to us. We must be able to explain creation, revelation and the Incarnation and Redemption in one coherent sweep of meaning, in which the Church, despite the many sins and failings of its members, is the continuing teacher of the truth for all the nations.

    A new synthesis

    Fr Edward Holloway (1918-99), meditating on his mother’s intuitions - she would say, inspirations - developed just such a theology. He was unsparing in his criticisms of the dry scholasticism taught in the seminaries of his day because it ignored how modern science had changed philosophy. His bishop told him he was a modernist, and despite his formidable intellectual gifts he was never allowed any academic or intellectual position in the Church. Then, in the cultural and intellectual revolution of the post-conciliar years, he was seen as a conservative because he criticised the liberal theology and catechetics that now became dominant, and he warned that influential voices in the Church were failing to teach the full, orthodox doctrine and morality of Catholicism. As the years go on, and the Church continues to flounder in the West and to be split over fundamental questions of morality, Fr Holloway can be seen as a prophetic voice, whose message is becoming more and more urgent if we are not to lose the battle with atheism completely.

    The Faith Movement

    The Faith Movement Fr Holloway founded has continued to promote his ‘line’ through this magazine, through our pamphlets and website and, most importantly of all, through our formation of young people through our Summer and Winter Sessions and other events. The many priestly vocations the movement has produced are evidence of its effectiveness. With this issue we launch a ‘new’ Holloway text, Matter and Mind: A Christian Synthesis

    It was his first attempt to write up his vision as a single book. Written in his first years as a priest in the late 1940s, it has freshness and urgency, though already authoritative and assured in tone. This first book was never published, and Fr Holloway later decided to rewrite it completely as Catholicism – A New Synthesis  which he published in 1969 and for which he is best known today.

    Matter and Mind is reviewed in our Book Reviews pages by Fr James Tolhurst who comments that it ‘has an immediacy and a conciseness to differentiate it from the final, more elaborate version twenty years later.’ We also publish a brief extract from it in our ‘Holloway on …’ section – though extracts can hardly do justice to the breadth of the book’s vision.

    Importance

    Fr Roger Nesbitt, another of the young priests Fr Holloway influenced and who was to become his chief collaborator and the co-founder of the Faith Movement, has edited this text for publication. As he writes in his Introduction, ‘We are now publishing this edition of  Matter and Mind: A Christian Synthesis in the hope that it will help many more to understand the vital importance of the vision Fr Holloway has given to us.’

    Fr Holloway himself boldly wrote that ‘the basic principles which underlie this work … give to the Church the new key she needs to unlock a deeper treasure vault of the deposit of the Faith, and to bring forth from its depths new things and old for the salvation of men’. He would have been the first to acknowledge that others could and would write more and better on this, the great issue of our age. But who else is doing this? May Our Lord who is Wisdom, and who renews the Church in every age, help this prophetic voice to be heard.