The Magi: not just a story.

The Magi: not just a story.

Available for the next few weeks, BBC iPlayer has an interesting exploration of astronomical possibilities for the Star of Bethlehem (though beware a juvenile short section from The Life of Brian, and a lazy equivalence of pre-modern science astrology and “devout Christianity”.

The blogger Mark Shea has written a relevant article explaining:

"Whether [the star] was a natural or supernatural event, we do not know. We do know that Jupiter was in conjunction with Saturn three times in seven months in 7 B.C. We also know that Mars joined them and produced a very striking configuration at about that time. Further, there [was] … an occultation of Jupiter by the moon in 6B.C., with Jupiter, the royal planet, dramatically re-emerging from behind the moon. An ancient Chinese chronicle, the Ch’ien-han-shu, states that an object, probably a nova (a new star), was observed in March 5 B.C. and remained visible for 70 days.”

His other four pieces of evidence are 

  • “Matthew Chapter 2 itself”, [though not to be read as a modern fly-on-the-wall account].
  • “The historical wise men (magoi) appear to have been an [influential] priestly caste in eastern lands. …  [who] practised basic astronomy and astrology.”
  • A “significant Jewish population … had lived [in Persia] since the days of Nebuchadnezzar, five centuries before these events. The Magi could have known the sacred Jewish texts; this certainly fits in with Herod’s behaviour in slaughtering the innocents of Bethlehem. We know from non-biblical sources that Herod was paranoid about rivals to his throne.
  • Herod was an Edomite, historical rivals of the Jews, cf. Gen 27. The Edomites unwiitingly enabled Balaam’s prophecy, Num 24:17-19, “a star shall come forth out of Jacob, and a sceptre shall rise out of Israel; … Edom shall be dispossessed”. “A paranoid Edomite king, Herod, would have been unnerved by the Magi’s report of a star and their question, “Where is he who has been born king of the Jews?”. Herod had proved himself willing to murder his own son to protect his throne, so might well have not hesitated to kill the children of people in an obscure village if he thought it would keep him from being dispossessed”


Comments to (which will be moderated) or twitter to @faithmovuk


Faith Magazine

November - December 2017

Recent Blog Posts

  1. Weinstein and Modern Judgmentalism

    Weinstein and Modern Judgmentalism
    The Harvey Weinstein affair has unleashed a can of worms. There has been a series of exposures concerning sexual offences or inappropriate sexual behaviour of MPs, celebrities and others. There is no doubt that sexual harassment, carried out mostly by men, deserves condemnation and certainly ther...
    Read More
  2. Islam and Terrorism

    Islam and Terrorism
    We are all aware of the horror of the terrorist attacks in recent years and of the senseless attack outside the mosque in Finsbury Park, London. It is inspiring how brave those who work in the emergency services are and how strong the community support has been in all these cases. As Christians, ...
    Read More
  3. Flirting with Fideism

    Flirting with Fideism
    In America magazine John J. Conley, S.J., of Loyola University argues in effect that we need a new synthesis of faith and reason given that “the world [of neo-scholastic philosophy] has disappeared”.He invites us to make “the synthetic passage through both Athens and Jerusalem t...
    Read More
  4. The Trump Election and Freedom of Thought

    The Trump Election and Freedom of Thought
    In a recent “Points of View” episode on BBC Radio 4[1], the well-known philosopher, Professor Roger Scruton, gave a reasoned analysis of something that may explain the surprise election of Donald Trump in America and of the Brexit vote here in the UK. Although clearly not a supporter ...
    Read More
  5. Bishop Barron Misses the Impact of Modern Science

    Bishop Barron Misses the Impact of Modern Science
    On his blog and in a recent Catholic Herald piece (9.9.16) Bishop Robert Barron offers some excellent reflections upon a recent Pew survey looking at reasons why young people are leaving Christianity in droves. He well shows how Roman Catholic leaders and teachers are dangerously underestimating ...
    Read More
  6. Jeff Mirus illustrates the fulfillment of Holloway's 1950 prediction.

    Jeff Mirus illustrates the fulfillment of Holloway's 1950 prediction.
    Jeff Mirus writes here on modern murder mystery novels. He says “Unfortunately, I’ve run into a number of telling cultural trends in these stories which make it more difficult to relax and enjoy the solution to 'a good clean murder'". He well articulates the over represen...
    Read More