A Compelling Coherence

A Compelling Coherence

A Compelling Coherence

Joanna Bogle FAITH MAGAZINE November - December 2015

FAITH magazine interviews Fr Roger Nesbitt and explores the origins of the Faith Movement

When Father Roger Nesbitt celebrated the 40th anniversary of his ordination in 2007, he was presented with a scroll signed by almost forty priests, each of whom owed his vocation, at least in part, to Fr Nesbitt's example.

A schoolmaster, a parish priest, a youth leader, and a co-founder of the FAITH Movement, Fr Nesbitt is now (sort of) in retirement – but remains an active speaker and preacher at FAITH events, and the dynamic teacher he has always been.

“It's a long story” he says, when I ask him to talk about the origins of the FAITH Movement. We are enjoying the warm hospitality of Mgr and Mrs Keith Newton, at the Rectory of the Ordinariate Church in central London, with a pot of tea in the large dining-room. In the church crypt – currently undergoing refurbishment – the popular Evenings of Faith attract good crowds, and Fr Roger has been among recent speakers.

First Meeting

“I first met Fr Edward Holloway when I was at Imperial College – I was doing a degree in chemical engineering, and was secretary of the Catholic Society and he came to give a talk.  He spoke about Teilhard de Chardin  - with whom he disagreed - and I didn't really know what he was going on about. But I knew he had something of importance to say, and I wanted to know more.

“I went to work for the Atomic Energy Authority for a year, and was returning to Imperial College in London to do a doctorate. But I thought 'What am I going to do with my life?' And I had the thought to talk to Fr Holloway. 

“When we met, he said after a short while 'I think you have a vocation to the priesthood'.  We were talking about this idea of a synthesis between science and religion. I had been five or six years in the scientific world, and what he was saying about this synthesis really clicked with me and made sense. Within six months I was in the seminary.”

At the Seminary

Studying at St John's Seminary, Wonersh, he read Holloway's early work Matter and Mind and visited him during the holidays.  But meanwhile, dramatic things were happening in the Church and seminary life was powerfully affected. “When I arrived, it was 1961, just before Vatican II. There was a recognition of a need for change –  the stuff we were being taught just didn't make sense and was unconvincing. There was a need for a new intellectual coherence”.

“But then – there was this implosion, the dramatic questioning of everything: the whole seminary and its message seemed to be disintegrating. It was as though nothing could hold it together. I wrote to the Bishop, worried sick about what was happening. 

“By now I was a deacon: they didn't know what to do with me. They wanted me to leave the seminary. The John Fisher School at Purley was looking for a chemistry teacher, so after ordination  I was sent there.”


And that was how the adventure began. Holloway was rewriting his book – later to be published as Catholicism, a New Synthesis -  and in the confusion of those immediate post-Vatican II years, the message of what was to become the FAITH Movement emerged with a compelling coherence:  “Christ as the fulfilment of creation – the whole evolution of the universe, the law of control and direction. This explains the creation of man and the soul/body relationship.”

The FAITH message centres on an understanding of Christ as the centre and meaning of all things. “The world was created for the sake of the Messiah: this is the Jewish understanding and is profoundly correct. We are made for God – man's environment is God. The psalmist sings of this: 'As the deer yearns for running streams, so my soul yearns for you O God'.” 

“The incarnation wasn't only because of human sin – Christ didn't come just because we sinned. He is the reason for the whole of creation. And we are made for union with him. Without this understanding, even our human biology doesn't make sense: the human brain is too large and ought not even to exist in its present form. It exists because of our souls and because we are designed to be in union with God.”

The Reality of Things

The weakness of the philosophy as taught in the seminary at that time was revealed when it became clear that it wasn't providing answers to the questions students were raising “And a dialogue wasn't even encouraged. The Church had become dissociated from the way people thought, and from the reality of things: there was no new synthesis and there was a desperate need for one.”

“I remember writing an essay on de Chardin's Phenomenon of Man. He is clever and poetic but he confuses spirit and matter and God and creation, and he certainly doesn't believe in Original Sin, or have any real grasp of the difference between the soul and the body. What was needed was the truth: making sense of it all.”

And so the FAITH Movement began: a magazine, initially called Kephas, meetings, talks, and a group of priests joining together to affirm essential truths. At first, the theme was not so much an emphasis on a new synthesis as simply a gathering together of priests who sought to be orthodox in their beliefs and loyal to the Church and the Magisterium. Then as things developed, the emphasis on the new synthesis emerged as central.

Youth Movement

The youth movement was founded in 1972, an essential inspiration from Fr Holloway with support from Canon George Telford, who was director of education in the Southwark diocese.  The name was originally going to be “72” not because of the date, but because of the seventy-two who are sent out, as described in the Scriptures. But then some one came up with the name FAITH, and it stuck. The first youth gathering was held at Herne Bay in Kent and attracted some 40 young people. 

The growth has been huge, and steady. The annual summer gathering grew to huge numbers and has proved so popular that a Winter Session was added a few years ago, plus a separate event -  dubbed  “Baby Faith” -  for younger teenagers. Then there are Faith Family Days, retreats, local meetings, and a theology seminar – plus booklets, DVDs, the magazine, and more. The movement has fostered large numbers of vocations – and been instrumental in the foundation of Scotland's first new religious order, the Sisters of the Gospel of Life.

Fr Roger spent fourteen years at the John Fisher School – where a FAITH group still flourishes, thanks to Mr Daniel Cooper,  meeting weekly in an unbroken tradition now going back 40 years – and was then appointed parish priest at Folkestone in Kent. He retired some three years ago but the town is still his home.


The turmoil of the immediate post-Vatican II years gave way to the pontificate of Pope – now Saint -  John Paul of whom Fr Roger says “He repaired and rebuilt the Church. I don't think we fully realised the huge problems in the Church until we were able to look back on them, after he had begun to teach and teach, and to bring about changes and new hope.”

“And he had Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger with him – who will one day be declared a Doctor of the Church. He is a genius – there is no question. We all owe him a tremendous debt. These have been remarkable years. Things are very different from the 1970s.”

Highlights down the years have included a meeting with Cardinal Jean Danielou in the 1970s - “an extremely holy human being” - and support from America's Cardinal John Wright, whose writings on the importance of angels became a popular Faith Pamphlet. 

And an increasing sense of being involved with the formation of a new generation, at the heart of the Church in the early years of a new century: “Today the FAITH Movement is at a new stage – and perhaps its real work is only just beginning.”

Joanna Bogle  


Faith Magazine